Director – Arthur Lubin, Screenplay – Samuel Hoffenstein & Eric Taylor, Adaptation – John Jacoby, Based on the Novel by Gaston Leroux, Producer – George Waggner, Photography – W. Howard Greene & Hal Mohr, Music – Edward Ward, Makeup – Jack Pierce, Art Direction – Alexander Golitzen & John B. Goodman. Production Company – Universal
Claude Rains (Enrique Claudin), Nelson Eddy (Anatole Garron), Susanna Foster (Christine DuBois), Edgar Barrier (Inspector Raoul Daubert), Jane Farrar (Mademoiselle Biancarolli), Steven Geray (Vercheres), Fritz Feld (Lecours), J. Edward Bromberg (Amiot), Leo Carrillo (Signor Ferretti), Fritz Leiber (Franz Liszt), Miles Mander (Pleyel)
Mild-mannered Enrique Claudin is discharged from his position as a violinist with the Paris Opera’s house orchestra. Struggling to make ends meet, he pins all his hopes on selling a concerto he has written. He then discovers the concerto has been stolen by Pleyel, a music publisher he has submitted it to. In anger, Claudin strangles Plevel but during the fight has a tray of acid thrown in his face by Plevel’s assistant. With his face badly burned, Claudin flees and hides in the labyrinth of tunnels under the Opera House. Sometime later, there are rumours of a phantom haunting the opera house. With his disfigured face hidden behind a mask, Claudin appears and demands that the beautiful understudy Christine DuBois, who he had been secretly sponsoring for tuition before the accident, be made the opera’s diva. When his wishes are not complied with, he arranges a series of fatal accidents.
This was the second screen version of Gaston Leroux’s novel The Phantom of the Opera (1909), following the still definitive silent version The Phantom of the Opera (1925) starring Lon Chaney [Sr]. The 1925 film is an absolute classic due to Chaney’s memorably mad and contorted performance and its superbly Gothic climax venturing down into the cellars of the Paris Opera House. In the mid-1940s, Universal were enjoying a good deal of success with their Frankenstein and Dracula sequels and so, rather than create any kind of sequel to the Chaney film, which was really the first of their classic monster movies, they decided to remake it with the addition of colour and sound. (See bottom of the page for the other versions of The Phantom of the Opera).
Unfortunately, in remaking The Phantom of the Opera in sound and colour, all that Universal ended up doing was embalming it. A huge budget was thrown at the film and Phantom of the Opera 1943 is a production that cannot help but impress with its sumptuously colourful sets and costumery. It was shot in Technicolor at a time when the bulk of films made in the US studios were in black-in-white so the lushness would have been even more amazing if you want to consider the film through the eyes of the audience of its time. The opera house is a marvellously gilted coliseum of multi-storey boxes (which was actually rebuilt using the set from the 1925 film) filled with audiences in the hundreds. The underground system of tunnels is a fabulous series of (studio-bound) lakes and crumbling stone caverns. The cutting of the gold chandelier decorated with dozens of candles is the film’s most exquisite set-piece. Even if nobody else is going to let the production be an interesting, the set-designers are – when Nelson Eddy catches his fall on a curtain, it is not merely a curtain but a hundred foot drape in pure velvet, while Claude Rains’ Enrique doesn’t get to live in a mere poverty-laden flat but instead gets one with an angular roof and giant-sized intruding ceiling beams like something out of German Expressionism.
However, Arthur Lubin’s plodding direction is determined to wring any interest out of the proceedings. Everything in the film proceeds at a sedate pace as though it were a standard soap opera romance of the era. Even though Claude Rains plays the title character and central figure in the film, for instance, he is only third billed on the credits with the lead positions going to romantic hero Nelson Eddy followed by Susanna Foster who plays this version’s Christine. It is a film where all emphasis has been placed on the spectacle – the colour, the costuming, the sets, the music and staging – such that the horror elements ended up being forgotten. In comparison to the 1925 film with its magnificent evocation of the Gothic, all that we get here is a few shots of the Phantom’s lurking shadow, while the climactic abduction and venture down into the cellars to rescue Christine is something that is over within minutes. It is here more than anywhere else that you can trace the descent of The Phantom of the Opera from a Gothic horror story to the weepy Andrew Lloyd Webber musical, which bled out all horror elements and romanticised the story. It is no wonder then that this version of the story has gained a respectability more so than any other version up until Lloyd Webber – it is the perfect stuffily respectable desiccation of the story.
It is hard to take pint-sized Claude Rains’ Phantom seriously, he seems more like an indignant fox terrier than the forbiddingly mad figure that Lon Chaney memorably incarnated. Not to mention that with the casting of Claude Rains we have a Phantom who is only 5’6″ in height, meaning that even when he is threatening this film’s equivalent of the character of Carlotta (Jane Farrar), she looks taller than he does. As modern horror fans come to understand, the addition of backstory is almost always something that weakens an iconic horror character – characters seem to work far better when they are simply evil without any need to have to make them sympathetic. It becomes extremely difficult looking at weak-jawed and backboneless Claude Rains throughout the first thirty minutes and thinking “This wimp is supposed to turn into the marvellously mad figure enacted by Lon Chaney?” Even the burning of the Phantom’s face is a laughably directed scene – the girl picks up a flatbed tray of acid as though it is the most obvious thing to throw and then proceeds to stand half-a-minute as Rains just waits there before deciding to throw it at him.
The film also suffers from the addition of comedy relief with the mugging idiocy of stage-manager Steven Geray and in particular the romantic triangle between Susanna Foster and lookalike heroes Nelson Eddy and Edgar Barrier. Eddy and Barrier are played as though they are doubles, each with ridiculous little fake pencil mustaches. Their scenes are played for bumbling humour as they are constantly mirroring one another’s actions, offering Susanna Foster the same thing or trying to walk through the door at the same time and reacting with mutual stances of popping discomposure.
The sets for the film were later reused in The Climax (1944), which also featured Susanna Foster as a singer being controlled by Boris Karloff.
The Other versions of The Phantom of the Opera are:– The Phantom of the Opera (1925), starring Lon Chaney; Hammer’s The Phantom of the Opera (1962) starring Herbert Lom; Phantom of the Opera (1983), a tv movie starring Maximillian Schell; The Phantom of the Opera (1989), a slasher film starring Robert Englund, which involved time travel and had The Phantom selling his soul to The Devil; The Phantom of the Opera (1990), a quite reasonable tv mini-series starring Charles Dance; Dario Argento’s The Phantom of the Opera (1998) starring Julian Sands; and the big budget version of the musical The Phantom of the Opera (2004) starring Gerard Butler. Other variations on the story are The Phantom of the Paradise (1974), a satirical version that sets the story to rock music; a pornographic version Phantom (1998); Angel of Music (2008) about a modern reporter conducting an investigation into the truth of the story; Phantom of the Theatre (2016), a Chinese version that conducts some radically different takes on the story; and modernisations like The Phantom of Hollywood (tv movie, 1974), The Phantom of the Ritz (1988), Phantom of the Mall: Eric’s Revenge (1989) and a Disney Channel children’s tv movie The Phantom of the Megaplex (2000), which had the Phantom haunting respectively a movie studio, a movie theatre, a mall and a cinema multiplex, as well as the low-budget The Phantom of the Opera (2014) where the Phantom’s spirit is disturbed by a reality tv crew; and the story even being given an uncredited relocation to another planet in the Doctor Who episode The Caves of Androzani (1984).
Arthur Lubin other genre films include:- the Boris Karloff-Bela Lugosi mad scientist/brain transplant film Black Friday (1940); the Abbott and Costello Old Dark House comedy Hold That Ghost (1941); the Arabian Nights adventure Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves (1944); the dull Greek myth drama Night in Paradise (1946); It Grows on Trees (1952), a comedy about trees that grow money; the entire Francis the Talking Mule series begun with Francis (1950) and including Francis Goes to the Races (1951), Francis Goes to West Point (1952), Francis Covers the Big Town (1953), Francis Joins the WACS (1954), Francis in the Navy (1955) and Francis in the Haunted House (1956); The Thief of Bagdad (1961) with Steve Reeves; and The Incredible Mr Limpet (1964) wherein Don Rickles turns into a porpoise. The film was also produced by George Waggner who was most famous as director of the Lon Chaney Jr The Wolf Man (1941) and a number of B movies of the era including Mystery Plane (1939), Horror Island (1941), Man Made Monster (1941) and the aforementioned The Climax.