Director/Screenplay/Photography – Mark Atkins, Story – Mark Atkins & Jose Prendes, Producer – David Michael Latt, Music – Chris Ridenhour, Visual Effects – Mart Atkins, Eric Steele & Scott Wheeler, Makeup & Ghost Effects – Jeff Farley & Dirk Von Besser, Production Design – Emily B. Taylor. Production Company – The Asylum.
Michael Holmes (Drake Grenier), Lira Kellerman (Susan Grenier), Tomas Boykin (Harrison Dent), Barry Womack (Haley Grenier), Kimberly Ables Jindra (Sarah Winchester), Rob Ullett (James Clayhill), Jennifer Smart (Annie Winchester), Savannah Schoenecker (Officer Margo Hunter), David McIntyre (Officer Cooper)
Drake and Susan Grenier take up a caretaking job at the famous, reputedly haunted Winchester Mansion and move in with their teenage daughter Haley. No sooner are they there and they are surrounded by terrifying ghostly forces. After the spirits snatch Haley, they are forced to call on the services of neighbourhood paranormal investigator Harrison Dent.
Winchester House is a real-life locale that has gained much fascination as an allegedly haunted tourist attraction. The house was the construction of Sarah Winchester, the widow of the heir to the company that produced the Winchester Rifle. After the death of her husband, Sarah visited a medium in Boston who purportedly told her that she was haunted by the spirits of all who had been killed by the Winchester Rifle. Moving to San Jose, she started the building of a massive mansion using the substantial fortune she had inherited, believing that she needed to continually add to it to keep away the ghosts. Construction began in 1884 and lasted until her death 38 years later in 1922. The house is a decided oddity, filled with hallways that lead nowhere, doorways that open into walls and an obsession with the number thirteen, all according to her designs. When the house was damaged in the 1906 earthquake, Sarah simply had the sections affected boarded up and left the way they were. The reasons for this are put down to everything from her decaying mental health, lack of expertise in architecture and/or the belief that the maze-like construction would be confusing to the ghosts. The Winchester House also later became the basis of the big-budget film Winchester (2018).
The Asylum is a company that specialises in low-budget copies more famous films, all sold with soundalike titles designed to come out at the time of their namesake releases. See the likes of The Da Vinci Treasure (2006), Snakes on a Train (2006), AVH: Alien vs Hunter (2007), The Hitchhiker (2007), I Am Omega (2007), Transmorphers (2007), Allan Quatermain and the Temple of Skulls (2008), The Day the Earth Stopped (2008) 100 Million B.C. (2008), Sunday School Musical (2008), The 18 Year Old Virgin (2009), Abraham Lincoln vs. Zombies (2012), Age of the Hobbits (2012) and Atlantic Rim (2013), among others.
With The Haunting of Winchester House, The Asylum hit onto the idea of a string of haunted house films all sold with the association of a famous haunting or murder (something that is frequently scanty to the point of near non-existence). Subsequent others among these include Gacy House (2010), Anneliese: The Exorcist Tapes (2011), The Amityville Haunting (2011), A Haunting in Salem (2011), The Haunting of Whaley House (2012), 100 Ghost Street: The Return of Richard Speck (2012) and The Bell Witch Haunting (2013), most of which were conducted in the Found Footage format (although The Haunting of Winchester House is not).
Director Mark Atkins shoots the film cheaply on video. Unfortunately, the flat photography kills the atmosphere that a haunted house film needs to work. The house being shot in looks nothing like a mansion, nor one that was built in the early 20th Century. Atkins’ jumps are all tiresomely borrowed ones – red herring taps on people’s shoulders, an endless array of peripheral figures moving through the background of shots, shapes moving under sheets/quilts and so on. The score’s constant lurking, shrieking and lunging becomes overhyped in the endless attempts to generate atmosphere so much that it creates none at all.
The film picks up markedly with the introduction of Tomas Boykin’s paranormal investigator. Boykin has a striking piece of explanation where he talks about Stage 1 and Stage 2 ghosts as the difference between those that are stuck in limbo and those that are aware of their existence and much more dangerous. This gives the film a fascinating rationalisation of ghostly activity. The downside of it is that Boykin is abruptly killed off as soon as he starts attempting to exorcise the house and the rest of the film returns to the same level of dreary hyped scares. The plot thereafter goes from trying to generate scares to merely being a drama about giving the past closure. The film also reaches a creaky and well-over worn deathdream ending patented by An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge (1961) and most famously The Sixth Sense (1999).
The Haunting of Winchester House is made by Mark Atkins, a regular Asylum director who has also made the likes of Halloween Night (2006), Allan Quatermain and the Temple of Skulls (2008), Dragonquest (2009), Princess of Mars (2009), Battle of Los Angeles (2011), Sand Sharks (2011), Alien Origin (2012), Jack the Giant Killer (2013), Knight of the Dead (2013), Android Cop (2014), P-51 Dragon Fighter (2014), A Perfect Vacation (2015), Road Wars (2015), Planet of the Sharks (2016), Empire of the Sharks (2017), Jurassic School (2017), 6-Headed Shark Attack (2018) and Monster Island (2019).