Director/Producer/Makeup Effects – Mark Polonia, Screenplay – Billy D’Amato, Photography – Lukas R. Reynolds, Music – John Rayl & Greg Stanina. Production Company – Polonia Bros. Entertainment.
Jeff Kirkendall (Father Benna), Marie DeLorenzo (Amy Dukane), James Carolus (Jeremy Dukane), Austin Dragovich (Robby), Steve Diasparra (Father Jonas), Titus Himmelbeger (Photographer), Ken Vansant (Charles Humes), Yolie Canales (Bonnie Dukane), Todd Carpenter (Burglar)
Father Benna, whose brother conducted the exorcism of the Amityville House, hears the confession of Charles Humes, a convicted killer who is awaiting execution at the Amityville Asylum for the Insane. Humes tells how he took lumber from the Amityville House and used it in the construction of another house. This other house is now owned by Jeremy Dukane. Jeremy has a bad drinking problem that led to the death of his wife. Jeremy’s teenage daughter Amy now becomes possessed by the lumber in the house. She walks out, exhibiting powers that kill people. Father Benna comes to Jeremy, persuading him that they must conduct an exorcism to drive out the evil possessing Amy and the house.
Twin brothers Mark and John Polonia became filmmakers in the VHS heyday of the1980s. Beginning with Hallucinations (1986), the Polonia Brothers, who were then only eighteen years old, went on to make a series of horror films that became legendary for their cheapness. Over the next two decades, the two put out the likes of Splatter Farm (1987), Hellspawn (1993), Saurians (1994), How to Slay a Vampire (1995), Feeders (1996), Night Crawlers (1996), Bad Magic (1998), Terror House (1998), Feeders 2: Slay Bells (1998), Blood Red Planet (2000), The House That Screamed (2000), Hellgate: The House That Screamed 2 (2001), Dweller (2002), Gorilla Warfare: Battle for the Apes (2002), Night Thirst (2002), Holla If I Kill You (2003), Among Us (2004), Dinosaur Chronicles (2004), Peter Rottentail (2004), Preyalien: Alien Predators (2004), Black Mass (2005), Razorteeth (2005), Splatter Beach (2007), Wildcat (2007), Forest Primeval (2008) and Monster Movie (2008). John died of a heart aneurism in 2008. Since then, Mark Polonia has continued on as a solo director, making the likes of HalloweeNight (2009), E.V.E. of Destruction (2011), Empire of the Apes (2013), Camp Blood First Slaughter (2014), Amityville Death House (2015), Channel 13 (2015), Death Reel (2015), Jurassic Prey (2015), Bigfoot vs Zombies (2016), Sharkenstein (2016), It Kills (2017), Land Shark (2017), Revolt of the Empire of the Apes (2017), Alien Surveillance (2018), Battle Bots (2018), Frozen Sasquatch (2018), Ghost of Camp Blood (2018), Bride of the Werewolf (2019), Deadly Playthings (2019), Amityville Island (2020), Children of Camp Blood (2020), Return to Splatter Farm (2020), Shark Encounters of the Third Kind (2020) and Virus Shark (2021).
Here Mark Polonia makes an Amityville film. The Amityville Horror (1979) was quite a success in its day, based on a book that made claims, which were later proven to be a hoax, about a family that stayed in a haunted house for 28 days before being driven out. This led to a large number of sequels and other films of increasingly slimmer connection to the original selling themselves solely with the Amityville name. These include Amityville II: The Possession (1982), Amityville 3-D (1983), Amityville: The Evil Escapes (1989), The Amityville Curse (1989), Amityville 1992: It’s About Time (1992), Amityville: A New Generation (1993), Amityville: Dollhouse (1996), the official remake The Amityville Horror (2005), The Amityville Haunting (2011), Amityville Asylum (2013), Amityville Death House (2015), Amityville Playhouse (2015), The Amityville Legacy (2016), Amityville: No Escape (2016), Amityville Terror (2016), Amityville: Vanishing Point (2016), Amityville: The Awakening (2017), The Amityville Murders (2018), The Dawn (2019), The Amityville Harvest (2020), Amityville Island (2020) and Witches of Amityville Academy (2020), while the parapsychological investigation of the house is also featured in The Conjuring 2 (2016).
The Polonia Brothers, whether together or Mark on his own, have been making films since the 1980s and the fifty plus films they have made have all been down the Z-budget end of the spectrum. Amityville Exorcism is no different to any of these. Its location is a regular suburban home – given the lack of production designer and even art director credit on the film, you can make a guess that Mark Polonia filmed in his own house or took his camera into the home of somebody he knew and filmed there.
Amityville Exorcism is mostly a possession and exorcism film. This leaves it resembling Amityville II: The Possession, one of the better legitimate sequels to the original, which also conflated the basic haunted house story with a possession and exorcism plot. What causes this film to plunge into ridiculousness however is the notion of possessed lumber – yes, a corner of the cellar in the house where we see stack of about a dozen pieces of timber. The lumber sits there innocuously and never actually does anything throughout but everyone reacts to it as though it were the cause of great evil.
The action seems to consist of not much more than Marie DeLorenzo wandering around the nearby woods, encountering various people and then causing them to undergo a meltdown. We get a really crappy swarm of optically superimposed bees in a shed at one point. The last twenty minutes of the film consist of an exorcism where Polonia has borrowed everything from the playbook established by The Exorcist (1973) and has Marie DeLorenzo with cracked, pasty face bound to the bed and taunting in a deep voice as priest Jeff Kirkdendall and her father James Carolus chant the rituals of exorcism.
The film suffers from bad acting, Jeff Kirkendall, a regular Polonia actor, is okay as the priest. On the other hand, Marie DeLorenzo becomes stilted once possessed. All her dialogue is crossly spat out and over-emphasised – surely the spoke equivalent of being written with each word capitalised. James Carolus as the father similarly overplays the drunk part and just seems a goofy over-eager guy trying to play a role not very well.
Mark Polonia had earlier made Amityville Death House (2015) and subsequently went on to make Amityville Island (2020), although I am unable to ascertain if any of these are meant to be connected. Jeff Kirkendall appears in all three films but plays different characters, while Marie DeLorenzo, James Carolus and Ken Vansant (all Polonia regulars) each also play in more than one of these but all in different roles.